5 Steps to Properly Screen and Manage Church Volunteers
Your volunteers are the hands and feet of your organization—they are priceless. And watching them serve and grow the body of Christ is one of the most rewarding aspects of ministry. But here’s the pragmatic reality: managing a volunteer team requires serious skills in risk management and stewardship. While most churches have formal, legally compliant HR processes for their paid staff, they often overlook the critical step of proper church volunteer screening and management.
Volunteer vs. Employee
Trying to navigate the difference? Our ministry HR experts can help.
This creates a vulnerability: Your church is legally responsible for the actions of those serving on your behalf. So, your HR practices should dictate that you treat your volunteer process with the same diligence, compliance, and legal rigor you apply to hiring a new employee. Let's walk through the five essential steps to creating a legally sound and spiritually responsible volunteer program.
1. Creating a Formal Volunteer Application Process
A consistent and comprehensive application is the foundation of effective church volunteer screening. It helps you gather necessary information, set clear expectations, and document the individual’s consent to your policies and procedures. This isn't about creating unnecessary hoops; it's about due diligence.
Every potential volunteer should complete a written application form, regardless of how long they’ve been involved with your ministry. Ask for their basic information, contact details, a list of relevant skills and experience, and a brief testimony or faith statement. Critically, this form must include clear authorization and disclosure for a volunteer background check. Without it, you can’t proceed to the next, most vital step!
The application should also require references. Ideally, non-family members who can speak to the applicant’s character and work ethic. Contacting these references is a non-negotiable step in the application review. It provides an extra layer of confidence in the person you are considering.
2. The Essentials of Background Checks for Volunteers
When it comes to protecting children in church or even vulnerable adults, volunteer background checks are the single most important action you can take and a fundamental part of responsible ministry stewardship. One of the biggest mistakes you can make is to think of a background check as “optional.”
The type of check needed depends on the volunteer's role. For any volunteer working with minors (i.e., children’s ministry, youth group, nursery, etc.) or finance, a comprehensive check is essential. This must include a search of national criminal databases and sex offender registries. If your volunteer will be driving for your ministry, add on a motor vehicle report as well. Skipping these to save a few dollars creates liability that far outweighs the cost of the screening.
When the results come back, you have to know what to do with them. Have a written child safety policy in place that dictates what findings disqualify an applicant from serving, particularly with minors. This policy should be clearly communicated and applied consistently to all staff and volunteers to avoid claims of discrimination.
3. Interviewing and Placing Volunteers Effectively
Once the background check is complete and the application looks good, the next step is a structured interview. This is not just a casual conversation; it is an opportunity for behavioral assessment and mutual clarification of expectations.
The interview process should be conducted by a ministry leader or HR administrator. Use standardized volunteer interview questions that probe character, conflict resolution skills, and agreement with the ministry’s theological and staff lifestyle expectations. Ask things like, "Tell me about a time you handled a disagreement," not just simple yes-no questions. This is also a chance to review specific volunteer policy and procedures and address the unique nature of serving in a Christian organization.
Also take this opportunity to discuss placement. While a volunteer might have their heart set on one position, they might not have the skills needed to execute it well. Proper placement is key to retention and effectiveness. Listen to their gifts and passions, and match them with a role that fits. This means you also need to have clearly defined volunteer role responsibilities so you can easily explain the roles they qualify for. This commitment to leveraging policy and screening is vital to protect your ministry.
4. Training and Equipping Your Volunteer Team
Even the most well-meaning individual needs to be trained. If you don’t already have one, put together a volunteer handbook that clearly outlines the church’s mission, core values, safety protocols, specific job duties, and reporting structure. (Hint: A lot of this can be copied over from your Staff Handbook!)
All volunteers, especially those working with children, must receive formal training on your child safety policy and any mandated reporting laws relevant to your location. Document this training by requiring volunteers to sign off that they received and understood the materials. Remember, though, that training is not a one-time event. Revisit these materials annually to reinforce best practices and refresh safety protocols.
Effective training for church volunteers can transform a group into a cohesive and highly effective team, ensuring everyone is on the same page regarding security procedures, emergency response, and spiritual accountability.
5. Ongoing Management and Volunteer Appreciation
The final step in a successful volunteer strategy is active, ongoing ministry volunteer management and appreciation. Volunteers thrive on clarity, support, and recognition.
Your volunteer managers—whether they are volunteers or paid staff—must be trained to provide regular, constructive feedback and encouragement. Meet with them regularly to celebrate successes, address challenges, and foster community proactively. This is the key to successful delegation.
Volunteer appreciation is also critical for retention. This doesn't have to be expensive. In fact, one of the best forms of appreciation is simply a handwritten note from the volunteer’s supervisor or a pastor on staff. Want to go father? Plan an annual appreciation dinner or mention their efforts from the pulpit or in a newsletter. Recognizing their sacrificial service acknowledges the significant spiritual investment they are making.
By consistently following these five steps, you move beyond merely finding someone to “help” to creating a robust, legally secure, and Christ-centered environment for your volunteers to truly minister to the people they are serving.
Want help understanding the differences between staff and volunteers? Our ministry HR experts are here to help!
Authored by the HRMS Team, a group of dedicated church HR experts who draw from extensive ministry experience to keep your organization compliant and healthy. Schedule a call and find out how we can help you simplify your organization’s HR here.