Top HR Mistakes Ministries Make
You answered the call to the ministry to serve people, not to become an expert in employment law and payroll regulations. Yet, the administrative side of leading a church or ministry can often feel overwhelming, pulling your focus away from your core mission. When people are your purpose, how you manage your staff and volunteers isn't just a background task, it's a direct reflection of your ministry's integrity and stewardship.
Ignoring human resources doesn't make the complexities disappear. Instead, it only leads to significant problems that distract from your mission, damage your reputation, and create unnecessary legal risks. But by understanding a few common pitfalls, you can protect your ministry, care for your team well, and create a healthy organizational foundation that supports your ministry for years to come.
Need Help fixing HR mistakes?
HR On Call give you a dedicated ministry HR expert in your corner.
Why Proactive HR Is Vital for Ministries
Thinking about Human Resources proactively is a form of risk management for ministries. It’s about building a framework that protects your church, your leadership, and the people you employ. Good HR practices ensure fairness, clarity, and consistency, which helps build a positive and trusting work environment.
When you have clear policies and procedures, you reduce the chances of misunderstandings that erode team unity. This isn't about creating a cold, corporate culture. It's about being wise stewards of the people God has entrusted to your care and minimizing the potential for church legal liability.
Ultimately, solid HR practices free you up to focus on ministry. When your team feels secure, understands expectations, and knows procedures are applied fairly, they can perform their duties with greater confidence and purpose. This creates a stronger, more effective team ready to advance the ministry’s vision.
Mistake #1: Misclassifying Employees as Contractors
One of the most frequent and costly church HR errors is misclassifying employees as independent contractors. The temptation is understandable—it seems to simplify payroll. However, the IRS has strict guidelines for determining a worker's status and getting it wrong can lead to significant back taxes, fines, and penalties.
The main factor is control: If your ministry dictates how, when, and where the work is done, that person is likely an employee. This applies to roles like the part-time nursery worker, the weekly custodian, or the sound technician you require to be there for specific services and rehearsals.
Simply calling someone a "contractor" or having them sign an agreement doesn't change their legal status. If you provide the tools, set the hours, and direct the work, they are an employee in the eyes of the law. These kinds of church payroll mistakes are easy to make, but difficult and expensive to fix.
Correctly classifying workers from the beginning is a foundational aspect of ministry compliance issues. Taking the time to understand the difference protects both the worker and the organization.
Mistake #2: Not Understanding the Ministerial Exception
The "ministerial exception" is a legal doctrine that gives churches and religious institutions the freedom to choose their ministers without government interference. This is a First Amendment protection that allows you to make employment decisions for ministerial staff based on religious doctrine. It primarily applies to hiring, firing, and managing the job duties of employees who perform vital religious functions.
However, many ministries mistakenly believe this exception is a blanket protection from all employment laws. Spoiler: it’s not. The exception doesn’t typically apply to issues like sexual harassment claims or to employees whose jobs are not ministerial in nature, such as an administrative assistant or a janitor. Relying on this exception in any way for non-ministerial roles is a significant legal gamble.
Mistake #3: Improperly Handling Pastor Compensation
Pastor compensation is a uniquely complex area that trips up many church boards and administrators. One of the most common issues involves a pastor's "dual-status" for tax purposes. A pastor is generally considered an employee for federal income tax purposes but self-employed for Social Security and Medicare taxes.
This means the church should not withhold FICA taxes from a minister’s pay, and the minister is responsible for paying their own self-employment taxes (SECA). Properly structuring compensation requires understanding these specific pastor compensation rules to avoid creating tax burdens for the minister and reporting problems for the church.
A major component of this is correctly administering the pastor’s housing allowance. The allowance must be designated by the church board in advance, in writing, and cannot exceed the fair rental value of the home, furnished, plus utilities. Failing to follow the specific pastor housing allowance rules can result in the loss of this valuable tax benefit.
Mistake #4: Having an Outdated Staff Handbook
A Staff Handbook is a vital tool for communicating expectations and policies to your entire team. Operating without one, or with one that hasn’t been updated in the past two years, leaves your ministry vulnerable to claims of unfairness and inconsistency. An effective handbook clearly outlines everything from work hours and dress code to your policies on paid time off and social media use.
Your handbook should also include important legal statements, such as an at-will employment disclaimer, which clarifies that either the employer or the employee can terminate the employment relationship at any time, for any lawful reason. These are the kinds of details that are easy to overlook, but can become incredibly important in a legal situation. To prevent these kinds of oversights, it's wise to review your handbook annually.
Mistake #5: Inconsistent Policy Enforcement
Creating a detailed staff handbook is only half the battle. The other half is applying those policies consistently and fairly to every single employee. When leadership plays favorites or enforces a rule for one person but not another, it erodes trust and can create legal liability.
Selective enforcement is a primary driver of discrimination claims. For example, if you discipline one staff member for tardiness but ignore the same behavior from another, you create a perception of unfairness that can be difficult to defend. This is particularly important when it comes to the difficult process of firing a church employee, as any hint of inconsistency can be used to challenge the termination.
Mistake #6: Failing to Keep Accurate Records
Meticulous record-keeping is not just good practice; it's a legal requirement. Ministries must maintain accurate and confidential personnel files for every employee. These files should contain job applications, offer letters, performance reviews, disciplinary actions, and compensation details.
You also need to keep specific forms on file for designated periods. For instance, Form I-9s must be kept for all employees to verify their eligibility to work in the U.S. and must be stored separately from the main personnel file. Other records, like payroll information and documentation related to workplace injuries, also have specific retention requirements.
Proper documentation is your first line of defense if a former employee ever raises a legal challenge. It's also necessary for complying with laws like the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). While many smaller organizations may not meet the 50-employee threshold for FMLA for churches, maintaining accurate time-off records is still one of the HR best practices for nonprofits.
Mistake #7: Ignoring Potential Workplace Conflicts
Conflict is inevitable whenever people work together, and ministry is no exception. Ignoring disagreements or hoping they will resolve themselves is a recipe for a toxic work environment. Small issues can fester and grow into major problems that disrupt unity and harm your witness.
A proactive approach involves establishing clear, safe channels for employees to voice concerns without fear of retaliation. This could be a formal grievance policy outlined in your handbook, or simply a culture of open communication fostered by leadership. Addressing issues early and directly prevents them from escalating.
Many leaders fall for certain myths about how to handle their teams, assuming that Christians won't have workplace problems. Believing common myths about ministry HR can prevent you from addressing the root causes of conflict before they cause lasting damage to your team and culture.
Mistake #8: Making Poor Hiring Decisions
The success of your ministry is deeply tied to the quality of the people on your team. Rushing the hiring process or failing to perform due diligence can lead to long-term problems. Improper hiring practices not only result in poor performance but can also expose your congregation or constituents to potential harm.
A structured hiring process is important. It begins with a clear, well-defined job description that outlines the specific duties and qualifications for the role. It should be followed by consistent interviews, thorough reference checks, and mandatory background checks, especially for anyone working with children or finances.
Shortcuts in hiring can have serious consequences. A bad hire can damage team morale, requiring an enormous amount of management time, and potentially put your entire ministry at risk. Avoiding these outcomes means being disciplined and intentional with your process from start to finish.
Understanding where things can go wrong is only the first step. Take a deeper dive by learning about the five common hiring mistakes many ministries make and how to avoid them in your own process. These church administration errors are preventable with the right approach.
How to Avoid These Common HR Mistakes
Navigating the landscape of ministry or church HR can feel complex, but protecting your ministry is achievable. Taking intentional, steady steps to build a strong HR foundation will reduce your risk and create a healthier work environment. Here are some practical ways to get started:
Conduct an audit of current practices. Review how you classify workers, handle payroll, and store employee records. Compare what you are doing with established best practices.
Develop and update your Staff Handbook. Ensure your policies are clear, legally sound, and reflect your ministry's values. Have it reviewed by a professional familiar with both ministry operations and employment law.
Provide training for anyone with supervisory responsibilities. Equip your leaders to handle hiring, performance reviews, and policy enforcement consistently and fairly.
Prioritize documentation. Get in the habit of documenting important conversations, performance issues, and policy decisions. Good records are invaluable!
Seek expert guidance when you need it. You don't have to be an expert in everything. Regularly partnering with professionals who specialize in HR for ministries can provide the peace of mind and protection you need. For a comprehensive overview, consider reviewing the top areas where churches fail to be compliant to spot potential blind spots in your own organization.
Taking these proactive steps isn't about adding another burden to your plate. It's about being a faithful steward of the people and mission you have been called to lead. A strong HR foundation allows your ministry to operate with integrity and confidence.
By addressing these common mistakes, you do more than just avoid legal trouble. You build a culture of trust, clarity, and safety that empowers your staff to do their best work, allowing you to focus more of your energy on the mission that truly matters.